Temple in Israel

No Future for Israel? Supersessionism 101

Israel is controversial. For the last seventy-five years, the nation of Israel and its enemies have dominated the headlines. The recent worldwide surge of antisemitism and anti-Israel protests in response to the Israel-Hamas conflict is shocking, albeit predictable. But controversy about Israel is not just relegated to the geopolitics of the Middle East. Israel is also very controversial among Christian theologians. There is great disagreement and division about the future of national Israel. Will Israel be saved and restored in the future? Or, have God’s promises to Israel been fulfilled in Christ and the church?

In this article I will attempt to explain what supersessionism is, some of its interpretive key features, and why I disagree with it. Instead, I will argue that God plans to save national Israel and restore it. 

Understanding Supersessionism

What is supersessionism? Michael Vlach defines it as “the view that the NT church is the new and/or true Israel that has forever superseded the nation Israel as the people of God.”1 The term supersessionism originates from the Latin roots super (“on” or “upon”) and sedere (“to sit”) meaning “displace” or “supplant.” Some theologians use “replacement theology” or “fulfillment theology” as interchangeable labels for supersessionism. Supersessionists generally prefer fulfillment theology and dislike the label of replacement theology as it is perceived to mischaracterize their position. One’s view of Israel directly affects two major doctrines: ecclesiology and eschatology. In relation to ecclesiology, non-supersessionists maintain a distinction between Israel and the church. In relation to eschatology, non-supersessionists hold to a dispensational premillennialism. There are three basic versions of supersessionism: punitive, economic, and structural.2

  • Punitive supersessionism argues that Israel permanently lost its covenant standing as punishment by God because of its hardened unbelief, persistent rebellion, and rejection of Jesus. Notable advocates of punitive supersessionism include many of the early church fathers and Martin Luther. 
  • Economic supersessionism contends that God’s sovereign plan was to replace or fulfill the nation of Israel as the people of God with the church, “new Israel.” Ethnic Israel served its purpose in God’s plan. Its covenant and purpose essentially expired with the coming of Christ and the dawning of the new covenant. This version of supersessionism was held by a few early church fathers and would represent most supersessionist interpreters today, such as N.T. Wright and most in the progressive covenantal camp.3
     
  • Structural supersessionism is a bit harder to define because it is more of a consequence of supersessionism rather than a separate version. This variety of supersessionism asserts that the Old Testament has become mostly obsolete partly because of the framework of the canon and partly because of the rise of Christianity. The church’s doctrine and practice depend mostly upon the New Testament, and consequently the Old Testament is relegated to a historical footnote. Vlach summarizes Soulen’s assessment: “[M]ost supersessionists have adopted a hermeneutical approach that ignores or removes the Hebrew Scriptures of the OT from having a voice.”4
     

It is important to note that these varieties of supersessionism are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Supersessionists may hold one or all varieties to one degree or another.

The Defining Issue: Israel’s Restoration

The defining issue for supersessionism is the future restoration of Israel. Vlach states, “In short, some supersessionists believe there will be a future salvation of Israel, but no supersessionists hold that there will be a restoration of the nation Israel.”5 Consider, for example, Doug Moo’s and Tom Schreiner’s similar interpretation of Romans 11:25-27. Both of these prominent New Testament scholars see an end-time turning among ethnic Jews to Jesus Christ near His Second Coming. But both reject the idea that the nation of Israel is restored or that Israel will be reinstated to the promised land. Instead, Moo and Schreiner believe these Jewish believers will merely join the church.6 Schreiner concludes, “[Paul] teaches that the church is the new Israel and that there is a future salvation for ethnic Israel. . . . Ethnic Israel, by believing in Jesus Christ, becomes part of the true Israel, the genuine people of God.”7 The future salvation of Israel is a common view held among moderate supersessionists. Stronger supersessionists, however, see no future revival occurring among ethnic Israel and simply interpret “all Israel” in Romans 11:26 as the church. N. T. Wright, for example, sees “all Israel” in Romans 11:26 as “all the family of Abraham—and that includes believing Gentiles as well as believing Jews.”8 John Calvin took a similar position.9

Many years ago, my high school Sunday school teacher, David Young, helped me understand God’s dealings with the nation of Israel. He drew railroad tracks on the board representing God’s program. He explained that during Old Testament times, God was primarily working in and through the nation of Israel’s train. Next, he drew a side rail and explained that after Christ’s first advent, God temporarily sidelined the nation during the church age. The church is the current train on God’s railroad tracks. But, in the drawing, there was an on-ramp for Israel’s train to come back onto the railroad tracks after Christ’s Second Coming. This essentially illustrates the non-supersessionist position. The supersessionist position would change the illustration. There would be only one track with one train. For supersessionists, national Israel is either derailed at Christ’s First Coming (punitive supersessionism) or is simply transformed into new (or true) Israel as the church (economic supersessionism).

Hermeneutical Keys of Supersessionism

How do supersessionists arrive at their understanding of Israel and the church? I will present four hermeneutical keys to supersessionism. First, supersessionists generally see Jesus as the true Israel who fulfills all of Israel’s covenants, promises, and prophecies. Brent E. Parker writes, “Jesus is the ‘true Israel’ in that he typologically fulfills all that the nation of Israel anticipated and hoped for; Jesus is the one who brings to completion the covenants, inaugurates the kingdom, and establishes the prophesied new covenant with his blood.”10 Therefore, since all church-age believers (both Jews and Gentiles) are united to Christ, the church becomes the new “Israel of God” (Galatians 6:16). This argument is like the ultimate theological trump card—no matter what details are found in God’s promises and covenants to Israel, Christ fulfills them. A common proof text for this approach is 2 Corinthians 1:20, “For all the promises of God in Him are Yes, and in Him Amen, to the glory of God through us.” For example, in relation to 2 Corinthians 1:20 David Garland states, “All of God’s promises to Israel find their yes in him.”11 To summarize, supersessionists assert two things. First, Jesus typologically fulfills OT Israel; and second, the church, through Christ, inherits the promises of Israel.12

The main problem with this approach is replacing Israel with Christ. Most non-supersessionists believe that Jesus in some way recapitulates or represents the nation (e.g., Matthew 2:15, Hosea 11:1). Most would also agree that the believers’ union with Christ is essential for Jews and Gentiles to receive covenantal blessings. But the inference that Christ replaces the nation is flawed. This logic leads to the dismissal of several promises of God about the nation of Israel. In addition, I believe that 2 Corinthians 1:20 confirms the exact opposite point that supersessionists make—because God and Christ are trustworthy, every promise of God will be fulfilled as they were originally promised and originally understood. Passages like Hebrews 6:13-20 and Romans 11 make this very same point. To alter the promises of God impugns the very character of God.

Here is an illustration to make my point. Let’s say I promise to take my oldest child, Krista, for a meal with all the fixings at her favorite restaurant. Later, instead of taking Krista, I take my youngest child, Makayla, to that same restaurant. When we get home, I tell Krista that Makayla’s meal fulfills my earlier promise to her. How do you think this will go over in our house? Not good! Not only will Krista doubt my promises, but so will all my family members. Regardless of the meal with Makayla, I still owe Krista her meal. If you haven’t figured it out, Krista represents Israel, and Makayla represents the church. Our God keeps his promises!

Second, supersessionists rely heavily upon typology to assert that Christ fulfills Israel’s promises. Supersessionists assert that the typological relationship between Israel (the type) and Christ (the antitype) means that Israel is completed or fulfilled and therefore no longer serves any purpose in God’s plan. The type is “transcended and surpassed by the arrival of the NT antitype.”13 This approach to typology leads to the dismissal of any literal fulfillment of the nation of Israel. Darrell Bock calls this kind of typology “a false typological reading.”14 Antitypes need not escalate in such a way as to cancel the original historical-grammatical meaning of the type. In addition, many of the promises of God are simply not types and should not be interpreted typologically. Instead, they should be read literally as they were originally intended to be understood.

Third, supersessionists regularly prioritize the New Testament over the Old Testament. This leads to reinterpreting Old Testament passages by reading New Testament passages back into the Old Testament. Consider Gary Burge’s comments on the land promises to Israel: “For as we shall see . . . while the land itself had a concrete application for most in Judaism, Jesus and his followers reinterpreted the promises that came to those in his kingdom.”15 I would argue that further revelation can add to our understanding of an earlier text (i.e., progressive revelation), but it can never change the original authorial intention of the passage. This leads non-supersessionist scholars to argue for a more consistent application of the historical-grammatical method of interpretation and Old Testament prioritization.16

Fourth, supersessionists emphasize the ultimate fulfillment of God’s covenant promises to the neglect of the intermediate fulfillment with Israel. In other words, nearly all kingdom promises in the Old Testament fulfill Revelation 21 and 22, rather than Revelation 20. For example, let’s consider how supersessionists interpret the land of Israel. Oren R. Martin starts with the premise that land in Scripture is typological and is fulfilled in Christ. He argues, however, that the land promises in the Old Testament point, not to Israel receiving the promised land but to the international kingdom of God encompassing the entire world. So, the promised land is not Israel, but the world. Martin writes concerning the land promises in the Abrahamic Covenant, “the ultimate inheritors of the patriarchal promises are not restricted to a national entity but extend to an international community.”17 While I would concur that the kingdom of God will ultimately culminate with the New Heavens and New Earth of Revelation 21 and 22 and envelop all creation, I would argue that there is also an intermediate kingdom of God, a Millennial reign of Christ in Israel among the nations (Psalm 2, Revelation 20). Supersessionism does not do justice to the details of Old Testament promises to Israel.

The Case for Israel’s Restoration

What does the salvation and restoration of Israel look like according to Scripture? The restoration of Israel means God will gather and save a remnant of ethnic Jews near Jesus’ Second Coming (Ezekiel 36-37, Isaiah 59:20, Romans 11:25-17), fulfill His covenant promises to Israel (Genesis 12:1-3, 2 Samuel 7:12-14, Jeremiah 31:31-37), enthrone the Messiah in Zion and exalt Jerusalem as the capital of His kingdom and center of worship (Psalm 2, Psalm 110, Isaiah 2:1-4, 9:6-7, 24:23, Micah 4:1-3, Zech. 14:16, Zeph. 3:9-10), restore national Israel geographically to the full promised land (Genesis 12:7, 13:15, 15:18-21, 24:7, 26:4, Numbers 34:2, Deuteronomy 34:4, Nehemiah 9:8, Isaiah 2, 19), establish national Israel in its mediatorial role among the nations in the kingdom of God (Isaiah 2; 11, 60-62, Zechariah 14, Revelation 19-20), and subjugate the nations to the Messiah’s rule (Psalm 2, Psalm 110, Zechariah 14). The biblical prophetic witness is clear that God will build a theocratic kingdom with Israel at its center. God’s kingdom will be characterized by worldwide peace, prosperity, righteousness, justice, sovereignty, and worship of the one true God. The kingdom will have many aspects: political, national, economic, social, and religious.

Of course, this interpretation of the kingdom of God points to the pre-millennial return of Christ and a literal Millennium, in which Christ will rule for 1,000 years on the earth (Revelation 20:1-6). The future restoration of Israel means that “. . . the millennial kingdom anticipates an administrative structure where national Israel again assumes a central place as the home of the reigning Messiah, in the midst of the nations who also respond to the Christ.”18 Ezekiel 36-39 makes it clear that God will use the future salvation and restoration of Israel to glorify Himself by revealing Himself to the nations (Ezekiel 36:36, 38, 37:6, 13, 14, 28, 39:25-29).19

Conclusion

In Romans 11:1 Paul asks this question: “I say then, has God cast away His people?” His response is definitive: “Certainly not!” Contextually, it is very clear—God has a plan for the nation Israel. He plans to save and restore the nation. This will fulfill the covenantal promises.

This article first appeared in Frontline magazine, 2024. Used with Permission.

Works Cited

  1. Michael Vlach, Has the Church Replaced Israel? A Theological Evaluation (Nashville: B&H Publishing Group, 2010), 12, emphasis original.[↩]
  2. Kenneth Soulen, The God of Israel and Christian Theology (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1996). Many authors follow Soulen’s analysis, e.g., Vlach, Has the Church Replaced Israel, 12-17; S. E. Porter and A. E. Kurschner, “Defining Supersessionism” in The Future Restoration of Israel: A Response to Supersessionism (Eugene, Oregon: Pickwick Publications, 2023); Matthew Tapie and Pim Valkenberg. Aquinas on Israel and the Church: The Question of Supersessionism in the Theology of Thomas Aquinas (Eugene, Oregon: Pickwick Publications, 2014).[↩]
  3. See e.g., N. T. Wright, Paul and the Faithfulness of God. Vol. 4. Christian Origins and the Question of God. (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2013) and S. J. Wellum and B. E. Parker, eds., Progressive Covenantalism: Charting a Course between Dispensational and Covenant Theologies (Nashville: B&H Publishing Group, 2016).[↩]
  4. Vlach, Has the Church Replaced Israel, 17.[↩]
  5. Vlach, Has the Church Replaced Israel, 19, emphasis original.[↩]
  6. Douglas J. Moo, A Theology of Paul and His Letters: The Gift of the New Realm in Christ. BTNT (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2021), 559-60; Thomas R. Schreiner, Paul, Apostle of God’s Glory in Christ: A Pauline Theology (Westmont, IL: IVP Academic, 2006), 477-84.[↩]
  7. Schreiner, Pauline Theology, 483, emphasis original.[↩]
  8. N. T. Wright, Paul for Everyone: Romans, Part 2: Chapters 9-16 (London: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, 2004), 60.[↩]
  9. John Calvin and John Owen, Commentary on the Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans (Bellingham, WA: Logos Bible Software, 2010), 437.[↩]
  10. Brent E. Parker, “The Israel-Christ-Church Relationship,” in Progressive Covenantalism: Charting a Course between Dispensational and Covenantal Theologies, edited by Stephen J. Wellum and Brent E. Parker (Nashville: B&H Publishing Group, 2016), 45.[↩]
  11. David E. Garland, 2 Corinthians, NAC (Nashville: Broadman & Holman Publishers, 1999), 103.[↩]
  12. Parker, “The Israel-Christ-Church Relationship,” 47.[↩]
  13. Parker, “The Israel-Christ-Church Relationship,” 48.[↩]
  14. Darrell Bock, “A Progressive Dispensational Response” in Covenantal and Dispensational Theologies: Four Views on the Continuity of Scripture, edited by Brent E. Parker and Richard J. Lucas (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2022), 230.[↩]
  15. Gary M. Burge, Jesus and the Land: The New Testament Challenge to “Holy Land” Theology (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2010), 35.[↩]
  16. Michael J. Vlach, Dispensationalism: Essential Beliefs and Common Myths. Revised and Expanded (Los Angeles: Theological Studies Press, 2017), 27-30.[↩]
  17. Oren R. Martin, “The Land Promise Biblically and Theologically Understood” in Progressive Covenantalism, 260.[↩]
  18. Darrell Bock, “Summary Essay,” in Three Views of the Millennium and Beyond. Counterpoints (Grand Rapids: Zondervan Academic, 1999), 292.[↩]
  19. Alan Hultberg, “The Future Restoration of Israel” in The Future Restoration of Israel: A Response to Supersessionism (Eugene, Oregon: Pickwick Publications, 2023).[↩]
Douglas Brown

Dr. Douglas Brown

Seminary Dean at Faith Baptist Bible College & Theological Seminary | brownd@faith.edu | Other Articles

Dr. Douglas Brown is the Academic Dean of Faith Baptist Theological Seminary and a senior professor within the seminary. Dr. Brown received his Bachelor of Arts and Master of Arts from Faith Baptist Bible College and Theological Seminary, his Master of Divinity from Central Baptist Seminary, and Ph.D. from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. Dr. Brown has many years of experience as a youth pastor and assistant pastor in Iowa, Minnesota, and Illinois. He is an avid golfer and enjoys traveling. He and his wife, Tricia, live in Ankeny and have four children, two of whom attend Faith Baptist Bible College and Theological Seminary.

Posted in Eschatology and tagged , , , , .

Dr. Douglas Brown is the Academic Dean of Faith Baptist Theological Seminary and a senior professor within the seminary. Dr. Brown received his Bachelor of Arts and Master of Arts from Faith Baptist Bible College and Theological Seminary, his Master of Divinity from Central Baptist Seminary, and Ph.D. from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School. Dr. Brown has many years of experience as a youth pastor and assistant pastor in Iowa, Minnesota, and Illinois. He is an avid golfer and enjoys traveling. He and his wife, Tricia, live in Ankeny and have four children, two of whom attend Faith Baptist Bible College and Theological Seminary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *